Posted: Wed Apr 18, 2012 9:26 am Re: 2008 Fluval FX5
Unfortunately the latest filters from Fluval and Rena have been total crap. The Fluval G series is a shiny box with an LCD screen, overpriced media, and a price tag that makes your eyes bug out. The latest Rena / API filter is called the Nexx... another pile of rubbish. Tiny filtration capacity with proprietary media and a pump that goes in the tank. These two filter manufacturers have gone for ease of use products marketed for the brain dead consumer with proprietary media to continuously feed their greedy pockets. Boo. One day Fluval will stop making their best filter the FX5, and API/Rena will stop making the FX series - and that will be a sad day for those in the hobby.
Luckily there's still eheim. The classic series filters are probably the best filter on the market today... the only problem is the price. They've been around for years and years and I don't think they're going away any time soon.
Then there's the generic knock-off filters. Some are decent some come with a drip tray to set the filter in (DOH!) These are a gamble.
So for now we enjoy our FX5's and our Rena XPs. In 10 years... I bet the 30 year old eheim classic series filter will be the popular filter on this forum. I guess it will be a 40 year old design then.